Car Broker Services on Long Island & the Tri-State Area

Lease or buy your next car through a licensed, bonded broker in Wantagh who negotiates for you, not the dealership.

Getting a new car shouldn’t mean losing a whole Saturday at a dealership, getting pressured to sign, and then wondering whether you overpaid. My Own Car Guy Inc. is a licensed and bonded auto broker in Wantagh, NY, and has helped drivers across Long Island and the Tri-State area lease and buy cars since 2014. We work with every brand, apply the manufacturer rebates and incentives available to you, and give you honest advice that isn’t tied to any one dealer. Then we handle the legwork: we shop dealers, negotiate the deal and take care of the paperwork.

What Our Car Broker Service Includes

Every deal starts with a conversation. We ask what you drive now, what you want next, how you’ll use it, and what price or monthly payment works for you. Before we start shopping, we walk you through how the process works so you know what to expect.

A My Own Car Guy brokerage can include:

  1. Help deciding whether leasing or buying makes more sense for you
  2. Access to new vehicles from every brand, from luxury models to everyday commuters
  3. Contacting multiple dealers to find the exact make, model and trim you want
  4. Negotiating price and terms for you
  5. Applying all available manufacturer rebates and incentives
  6. Online credit applications for personal and business leases
  7. Handling the paperwork from start to finish
  8. Delivery of your new car to your home

Car Shopping Without the Dealership Runaround

The usual dealership visit costs you more than money. You spend hours on the lot and more hours in the finance office. You’re pushed to decide that day. Then you drive home not knowing whether every incentive was applied or whether the dealer down the road would have offered a better deal.


A car broker takes all of that off your plate. You don’t have to go from dealer to dealer yourself. My Own Car Guy contacts multiple dealers to find your vehicle and negotiates the deal for you. One client estimated he saved four to five hours compared with buying on his own, and he was confident he had the best pricing available.


Negotiating a car deal is also a skill. Lease terms, incentives and pricing change all the time, and it’s hard to know what’s fair when you only shop for a car every few years. Our brokers work these deals all the time, so you get the benefit of that experience without having to become an expert yourself.

Who Benefits Most From Using a Car Broker?

Working with a car broker is a good fit for many drivers, including:

Busy professionals and parents who don’t have hours to spend at a dealership

Drivers whose lease is ending who want their next car lined up without the hassle

Luxury car shoppers who want the right trim and options at a fair price

Commuters looking for a dependable, economical car on a set budget

Drivers whose car was totaled and who need a replacement quickly, without being taken advantage of

Business owners leasing vehicles for their company

First-time lessees who want the process explained in plain language

Do I Have to Go to a Dealership If I Use a Car Broker?


Usually not. When you work with My Own Car Guy, we deal with the dealerships and do the negotiating. Many of our clients have their new car delivered to their home and finish the paperwork there, so they never sit in a showroom.


It helps to know how a broker fits into the deal. My Own Car Guy Inc. is an automobile broker, not a registered new motor vehicle dealer. We don’t have contracts with any dealer or lessor, which lets us contact multiple dealers to find your vehicle. As New York law requires, we also disclose that we may be paid by the dealer, lessor or another party for helping to complete a lease.


Every deal is a little different, so if you want to know how pickup, delivery or signing will work for your car, just ask when you call. We’ll explain it up front so there are no surprises.

How Working With My Own Car Guy Works


01. Tell Us What You’re Looking For
Call (516) CAR-GUY-1 or send us a message. We’ll talk through the vehicle you want, your budget, and whether leasing or buying suits you better.


02. Complete Your Credit Application
Fill out our secure online credit application, or the business application if you’re leasing for your company.


03. We Shop and Negotiate for You
We contact multiple dealers, find your vehicle, apply every rebate and incentive you qualify for, and negotiate the deal.


04. Sign, Get Your Keys and Drive
We take care of the paperwork, and in many cases your new car is delivered to your door.

Gray two-story house with white double garage doors at dusk

Why Long Island Drivers Choose My Own Car Guy

Founder Danny Sandoval came to the car business from an unusual place. For more than ten years he worked as a medical massage therapist, treating patients who had been hurt in car accidents. Many of them had totaled their cars and were being taken advantage of when they went to replace them. Danny started helping them negotiate better deals. Then he helped friends and family, and the referrals kept coming. That’s still how the business works today: a simple, low-stress way to get a car, with someone in your corner.

Voted Best Luxury and Domestic Auto Broker on Long Island. Our clients voted us the winner in the Long Island Choice Awards.

Licensed and bonded. My Own Car Guy Inc. has been a licensed auto broker since 2014 and holds an Official Business Certificate from the NY Department of Motor Vehicles.

Every brand, every incentive. We aren’t tied to one manufacturer or lot, so our advice is based on what fits you, not what a dealer needs to move.

A team clients remember by name. Danny, David, Carlton and Mike are named again and again in our reviews for being patient, answering every question and getting clients the best deal possible.

Built on fairness. The Long Island Herald covered Danny’s mission to protect minority communities from unfair dealership practices.

A real local office. Visit us at 3020 Merrick Rd in Wantagh, across from Causeway Bait & Tackle.

The Lasting Value of Using a Car Broker

The benefit doesn’t end when you get the keys. You drive away confident that you got a fair deal, with the incentives applied and the terms explained, so you aren’t second-guessing it every time a payment comes due.


You also have someone to call when your lease is up or it’s time for another car. Many of our clients come back to us for their next car, and plenty say they’ll never go back to buying at a dealership on their own.

Let's Connect

Request a Quote

A&J Garage Doors corp.

Talk to Your Car Guy: Call or Visit Us in Wantagh

At My Own Car Guy Inc., our licensed broker team finds your next car, negotiates the price and handles the details, so you never have to deal with the dealership.

Call or Text:

(516) 227-4891

FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL MEDIA:

Reviews from Our Customers

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

“If you want to save yourself 4-5 hours purchasing / leasing a car, and be comfortable you have the best available pricing, use MyOwnCarGuy. They drop it off at your house and handle all the paperwork!”


Matthew V.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

“Absolutely amazing experience with My Own Car Guy! They made the entire car leasing process simple and stress-free from start to finish. David and Danny were professional, responsive, and kept me informed every step of the way. Highly recommend them to anyone who is sick of dealing with dealerships.”


Kristin G.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

“I had an excellent experience purchasing my car thanks to Carlton. He was professional, friendly, and made the entire process incredibly smooth and stress-free. Everything was handled right at my home, which made the experience even more convenient since I never had to leave the house.”


Tiffany L.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

“I cannot recommend Myowncarguy highly enough! Danny and David made this process so easy. I will never step foot in another dealership again. They worked with me to find the best car with the best rates.”


Christine D.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

“Carlton and Peter were both great throughout the process and truly got us the best deal in the area. I did my best to replicate or beat them but I couldn’t! They handle everything door to door. I would recommend them to anybody in the area.”


Andy P.

Ready for a Better Way to Get Your Next Car?

When you lease or buy through a licensed, bonded auto broker, someone is negotiating for you, not for the dealership. My Own Car Guy works with every make and model, applies the rebates and incentives you qualify for, and handles the paperwork. Your new car can even be delivered right to your door. No showroom, no pressure.

Call My Own Car Guy at (516) 227-4891 or get your free quote today.

Car Broker FAQs

  • What does a car broker do?

    A car broker finds, negotiates and arranges a vehicle purchase or lease for you. My Own Car Guy contacts multiple dealers, finds the car you want, applies the rebates and incentives available to you, negotiates the deal and handles the paperwork.

  • Can you help me lease and buy a car?

    Yes. My Own Car Guy helps clients both lease and buy new vehicles from every brand, and we’ll help you work out which option makes more sense for you.

  • How does My Own Car Guy get paid?

    As New York law requires, we disclose that My Own Car Guy Inc. may be paid by the dealer, lessor or another party for helping to complete a lease. Call us and we’ll explain exactly how pricing works for your deal.

  • What areas do you serve?

    My Own Car Guy serves drivers throughout Long Island and the Tri-State area from our office at 3020 Merrick Rd in Wantagh, NY.

  • How do I get started?

    Call (516) CAR-GUY-1, send us a message, or fill out our online credit application. We’re open Monday to Friday from 9:30am to 7:00pm and Saturday from 10:00am to 2:00pm.